drakyndra: The Music Meister demands you sing! (Black Hole with Ten and Rose)
([personal profile] drakyndra Aug. 29th, 2006 11:44 pm)
Was lurking around a few threads on the OG, when I stumbled upon a recent - and rather unexpected post from Teh Moff.

(From here)

In response to a previous commenter's "Writer Steven Moffat has all but admitted that The Doctor & Rose were sexually active as of the 'Doctor Dances' episode"

Teh Moff:
"I say, no I didn't! The whole scene was about the fact they WEREN'T at it - indeed, it was the Doctor being slightly hurt that Rose hadn't even considered him in that light.

There's precious little evidence they ever got up to anything, I'd have said - that it doesn't stop it being a love story, of course (it clearly was) but unrequited surely?

Oh, it's all sex with you lot, isn't it? And when the writer of Coupling says you're banging on about sex too much, it's time to start listening.

Steven Moffat
"

Did mine eyes just decieve me, or was the word "unrequited" just used to describe the Doctor/Rose relationship by someone in the know?

From: [identity profile] nostalgia-lj.livejournal.com


Unrequited from which side though? If he's talking the whole thing the presumably Rose is the one with the unrequited love because she's far more demonstrative so it'd be hard to argue she's the one without love. And she does say it in the end, unlike certain people who suddenly lose their magic affinity with time. Ahem.

I'm sure I've mentioned here before that I've had my doubts about Moffat as a member of any OTP Club on that one, which would make the sense since a truly non-aseuxal stance does require assuming the Doctor's loved and "danced" before and will again. Basically, from what I've seen of Moffat's views on the subject, One True And Only Love is incompatible with his own ideas.

And yeah, he's the one who seemingly had no qualms about pairing the Doctor up with a "perfect match" who isn't Rose and writing it as though Rose were not even an issue.

Though I do read that and wonder if he meant "unconsummated." Or something.
ext_5608: (bounce)

From: [identity profile] wiliqueen.livejournal.com


Though I do read that and wonder if he meant "unconsummated." Or something.

I had much the same thought. Even someone that good with Teh Wordz can biff it now and again.

After all, many of us post the way we talk, and isn't Steve supposed to be all autobiographical, specifically in his great talent for saying exactly the wrong thing at the worst possible time? ;-)

From: [identity profile] nostalgia-lj.livejournal.com


Doesn't seem very like him to deny Doctor/Companion romance where there's any possibility of it occurring.

From: [identity profile] nostalgia-lj.livejournal.com


"Unrequited" seems far too removed from the rest of what we're given. I think it'd be arguable and valid and whatever, or there could be something about how it's unrequited on both sides cos neither can give the other what they want, but it's still a bit hardcore.

From: [personal profile] fannishnonsense


neither can give the other what they want

Which I'd say is true, actually. I think the whole reason I ship them is because they're so obviously incompatible. But yeah, I can't imagine any of the writers actually arguing from that position.

From: [identity profile] nostalgia-lj.livejournal.com


I'm very distracted by what's apparently going on in your icon.

*stares*

But yeah. They wouldn't let them write it if they were going to say stuff like that in public. Ten years from now we'll get all the gossip about who shipped more than who and who had who else in the catering van.

From: [personal profile] fannishnonsense


Icons are fun.

And I want to know who had who else in the catering van! Why oh why doesn't this fandom have more RPF?

From: [identity profile] nostalgia-lj.livejournal.com


I want that icon quite a bit. *craves*


There should be more RPF. David/Rusty FTW

From: [identity profile] nostalgia-lj.livejournal.com


Are it shareable then hai? Hooray!

*takes it*

"names it "ten/rose oral sex"*

From: [personal profile] fannishnonsense


names it "ten/rose oral sex"

I think I may love you. I will prove this by declaring my intention to stay with you forever, even beyond the point of sanity

From: [identity profile] nostalgia-lj.livejournal.com


I has named it "dw - ten/rose public oral sex" which is a name that captures my glee. Is that what is actualy happening in it or I am just sick?

From: [personal profile] fannishnonsense


Well, I don't know if that was the intention, but it certainly looks like it, doesn't it?

From: [identity profile] drakyndra.livejournal.com


There is the possibility it's a bit of miswording. I was just so shocked to see that particular phrase to describe the ship, truly.

From: [identity profile] doylefan22.livejournal.com


Though I do read that and wonder if he meant "unconsummated." Or something.

That's exactly what I thought when I read. Love doesn't necessarily lead to sex. Especially when one of the partners is a 900 year old alien...
.

Profile

drakyndra: The Music Meister demands you sing! (Default)
drakyndra

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags